Putative Venezuelan coup attempt of 2004
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The putative Venezuelan coup of 2004 was a hypothesized plot to overthrow Hugo Chávez, who is the current President of Venezuela. According to Chávez and his supporters, the capture of several dozen individuals in May 2004 and other developments prove the existence of the purported coup plot, while the anti-Chávez opposition discounts the notion that any deeper meaning can be imputed to the raid and capture of the Colombian detainees or to other events.
Contents |
[edit] Baruta raid and the capture of Colombians
On May 9, 2004, Venezuelan police raided a ranch in Baruta, which is situated on the outskirts of the Venezuelan capital of Caracas. A total of fifty-five Colombian men were arrested. The raided ranch was owned by Roberto Alonso, a Cuban exile active in the anti-Castro movement and a leader of the Venezuelan opposition group Bloque Democrático. Shortly thereafter, they arrested 71 more men at a neighboring ranch that was owned by Gustavo Cisneros, another outspoken Cuban-Venezuelan Chávez opponent.
[edit] Allegations
[edit] Detainees as manpower for coup conspirators
One of the detainees allegedly stated that they had been offered 500,000 Colombian pesos to work on the farm. Upon their arrival at the farm, however, they were told that they instead would need to prepare for an attack on a Venezuelan National Guard base. The goal of the putative attack was allegedly to steal weapons and fully arm a 3,000-member militia. [1]
[edit] Detainees as victims of entrapment by foul play
According to other detainees and their Colombian families, most of those that were arrested were merely unemployed and impoverished peasants. Many of these men originated from the Cúcuta area; many of them also had at some point in their lives done military service in Colombia, thus qualified as Colombian military reservists. They had then reportedly been promised secure work in Venezuela, but were later betrayed. [2] The families of 68 detainees announced to the Colombian press in June 2004 their intention of travelling to Venezuela to argue for their relatives freedom, claiming that they fell to a setup. [3]. Another relative told the Venezuelan opposition press that the prisoners were being mistreated while in captivity [4]. The official press reported a government denial of this claim.
The family of a Venezuelan National Guard Captain arrested and accused of being implicated in the supposed paramilitary plot likewise denounced in the opposition press the possibility of a political persecution against those that would not share the Venezuelan revolutionary process. He was said not to be recognized when he was presented to the Colombian detainees.[5]. Some women and underaged children were also included among those captured suspected paramilitaries. The latter were speedily repatriated to Colombia by Venezuelan authorities [6]. The alleged paramilitaries were caught wearing Venezuelan Army uniforms and apparently had a single gun in their possession in the immediate area. At least two (other sources speak of between three and five) suspected paramilitary commanders were also reported to be in custody.
Opposition critics of the official Venezuelan government's version also mention that an attack by such a small number of fighters against a strongly defended Venezuelan military position and/or eventually the palace of President Chávez would amount to certain failure and virtual suicide on the part of those carrying out the alleged operation. Supporters of the government's version point to the claim that the captured men would only be part of a vanguard of allegedly some 3,000 potential operatives that would have been later introduced into the country.[citation needed]
[edit] Inconsistencies in the information
The government claims that the colombians were the manpower for a group of cup conspirators led by the opposition. However, there are some inconsistencies in these allegations:
- The police raid of the Baruta ranch was led by the Baruta police force, after being tipped by local people. Baruta's major (and its police force) is allied with the opposition, so it makes no sense that he would raid a ranch the opposition set up.
- After the colombians were detained, the Baruta police force called the political police (DISIP) for backup, and then the DISIP officers claimed that they were the ones who led the raid.
- Government officials claimed that the detainees were "Blood-thirsty murderers" and members of the Colombian guerrilla, however, when captured, the detained colombians had no weapons, no fighting skills, and brand new military uniforms.
These inconsistencies, coupled with the allegations of the detained's relatives, cast a shadow of doubt on the information presented by the government.
[edit] Proceedings against the detainees
During the judicial process, the number of the accused shrunk to 100 as several of the alleged paramilitaries were deported or collaborated with Venezuelan authorities. In October 2005, the Venezuelan prosecution asked for a sentence of 6 years for 57 to 62 of the alleged paramilitaries, while desisting to condemn between 38 and 43 of the men, which were considered to have been led to Venezuela under false pretenses and/or had apparentely suffered mistreatment from the alleged coup plotters. [7][8] [9]
On October 25, 2005, a Venezuelan military tribunal found 27 of the men guilty, sentencing them to 6 years in jail, and ordered the release and deportation of the other 73 Colombians. 3 out of 6 Venezuelan military officers accused of participating in the alleged plans for a coup were also condemned by the tribunal. [10]
[edit] Alleged links to Commandos F4
In June 2004, a Cuban Miami TV channel broadcasted a program featuring the Florida-based Commandos F4. Rodolfo Frometa, the Commandos F4 leader, said that his group was ready to carry out violent attacks against the Cuban government. Former Venezuelan army captain Eduardo García described the help he received from Commandos F4 to organize similar violent actions against the Chávez government. According to the TV program maker Randy Alonso, the US government would have recently earmarked $36 million to support such paramilitary groups. [11] U.S. officials and opposition figures in Venezuela have dismissed this claim. Alonso himself went into hiding, and many media reports (including his official website) stated that he had fled the country.
[edit] See also
 Topics related to Hugo Chávez  |
|
|---|---|
| Biography | Early life | Military career | Presidency |
| Political events | Coup attempt of 1992 | Coup attempt of 2002 | Recall referendum of 2004 | Putative coup attempt of 2004 |
| Elections | Presidential election of 1998 | Presidential election of 2000 | Presidential election of 2006 |
| Governance | Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas | Bolivarian Circles | Bolivarianism | Bolivarian Revolution | Cabinet | Constitution | Foreign policy |
| Bolivarian Missions | Barrio Adentro | Guaicaipuro | Hábitat | Identidad | Mercal | Miranda | Piar | Plan Bolivar 2000 | Ribas | Robinson | Sucre | Vuelta al Campo | Vuelvan Caras | Zamora |
| Reactions | Criticism | Media representation | The Revolution Will Not Be Televised | Súmate |
[edit] References
- Venezuelan Court Releases 2 Officers and 38 others Involved Destabilization Plan Oct 05, 2005, Alessandro Parma, Venezuelanalysis.com.
