Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards
Image:ccawards nomination banner2.png
smaller banner
Author(s) All webcartoonists
Website http://www.ccawards.com/
Update schedule Yearly
Launch date 2001
Genre Awards

The Web Cartoonist's Choice Awards (WCCA) is an annual event, since the summer of 2001, in which online cartoonists nominate and select outstanding webcomics in a variety of categories. The WCCA represents a form of peer recognition since voting membership is open, only, to the sole creator, writer, artist (including colorists), or webmaster of an online webcomic. Winners receive an individualized web banner for their site. Because the membership is made up entirely of people with some sort of online presence, all official business is transacted over the Internet.

The WCCA started in 2001 being hosted by Comic Genesis (then Keenspace)), with a separate forum. Since then the site has moved off to its own server.

In 2003, 2005 and 2006, the awards were presented in a "ceremony", which takes the form of multiple comics by different artists, containing their characters listing the nominees and declaring the winner. Planning problems resulted in the lack of ceremony in 2004, and the 2006 ceremony was delayed (see below).

Contents

[edit] Controversy

Controversy over the procedure - and even necessity - of the awards has existed since the beginning. Common claims are that the WCCAs are nothing more than a popularity contest and that the widely known comics such as Penny Arcade, Megatokyo and PvP are always nominated and usually win. By contrast, the awards are said to give little recognition to talented - but unknown - artists.

However, no comic has won an award all five years and only 5 comics have even received nominations each year.

The comic with the most awards are: Mac Hall: 2 in 2002, 4 in 2003, and 3 in 2004. Next is Chopping Block with 4 in 2001 and 4 in 2002. Then comes Penny Arcade with 2 awards in 2003 and 5 in 2004, Count Your Sheep with 6 awards in 2004, and Megatokyo with 4 in 2002 and 1 in 2003. PvP has the most nominations without a win — 2 in 2001, 5 in 2003, and 3 in 2004 — followed by Clan of the Cats — 3 in 2001, 2 in 2002, and 2 in 2003.

It has therefore been argued that the WCCAs increase interest in comics that voters may never have seen before. It also gives artists a chance to collectively praise the work of others, and encourages webcartoonists to participate as a community, and the WCCA staff continues trying to improve the awards with passing each year (such as adding more diverse categories, including one just for the year's newcomers).

In 2006 Eric Millikin's Fetus-X was nominated for "Best Romance Comic" but was later disqualified as inappropriate. The award ceremony was late due to technical issues, trailing the on-time annoucment of the winners by a week. An early, unfinished version of the ceremony was leaked on Comixpedia [1].

[edit] Results

[edit] 2001

Best Comic
Best Art
Best Writing
Best Site Design
Best Concept
Best Male Character
Best Female Character
  • Monique of Sinfest — by Tatsuya Ishida (Winner)
  • Alice of Alice! — by Michael McKay-Fleming
  • Wendy of Wendy — by Joshua Lesnick
  • Ms. BoxJam of BoxJam's Doodle — by BoxJam
  • Filis of Elf Life — by Carson Fire
Best Other Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Special Event
  • Keenvention — by Todd Michaels (Winner)
  • Web Comic Awareness Day
  • Party 2001
  • Bikeeni 2000
  • William Shakespeare 2001
Best Cameo
Best Romantic Comic
Best Serial Comic
Best Gag Comic
Best Reality-Based Comic
Best Minimalist Comic
  • BoxJam's Doodle — by BoxJam (Winner)
  • ? — by Aric McKeown
  • Arrogance In Simplicity — by Capheine
  • Triangle and Robert — by Patrick Shaughnessy
Best Science-Fiction Comic
Best Fantasy Comic
Best Superhero Comic
Best Anthropomorphic Comic
Best School-Based Comic
Best Dramatic Comic
Best Gaming Comic
Best Other Genre Comic

[edit] 2002

Best Comic
Best Art
Best Writing
Best Use of Color
Best Site Design
Best Male Character
Best Female Character
Best Supporting Character
Best Newcomer
Best Romantic Comic
Best Serial Comic
Best Gag Comic
Best Reality—Based Comic
Best Minimalist Comic
Best Anthropomorphic Comic
Best Science—Fiction Comic
Best Fantasy Comic
Best Superhero Comic

Supermegatopia by The Brothers Grinn (Winner)

Best Dramatic Comic
Best Gaming Comic
Best Other Genre Comic
Best Use Of The Digital Medium

[edit] 2003

This was the first year that artists were invited to sumbit "introductions" for the awards, creating the ceremony discussed above.

Outstanding Comic
Outstanding Newcomer
  • Anne Frank Conquers The Moon Nazis — by Bill Mudron (Winner)
  • Errant Story — by Michael Poe (Winner)
  • Elf Only Inn — by Josh Sortelli
  • Trilokan — by Suburi Y
  • Weirdism — by Liz Groenveld & Norna Ross
WCCA Advancement of Webcomics Award
Outstanding Art
Outstanding Technical Achievement
Outstanding Writing
Outstanding Original Digital Art
Outstanding Use of Flash
Outstanding Use of Infinite Canvas
Outstanding Website Design
Outstanding Black and White Art
Outstanding Character Design
Outstanding Composition
Outstanding Environment Design
Outstanding Line Art
Outstanding Use of Color
Outstanding Character Development
Outstanding Long Form Comic
Outstanding Short Form Comic
Outstanding Story Concept
Outstanding Anthropomorphic Comic
Outstanding Dramatic Comic
Outstanding Fantasy Comic
Outstanding Gaming Comic
Outstanding Gag Comic
Outstanding Reality Comic
Outstanding Romantic Comic
Outstanding Science Fiction Comic
Outstanding Superhero/Action Comic

[edit] 2004

Planning problems meant that there was no ceremony this year.

Outstanding Comic
Outstanding Newcomer
Outstanding Art
Outstanding Writing
Outstanding Use of Flash
Outstanding Use of Infinite Canvas
Outstanding Web Design
Outstanding Black and White Art
Outstanding Character (Visual)
Outstanding Character (Writing)
Outstanding New Character Design
Outstanding Environment Design
Outstanding Layout
Outstanding Use of Color
Outstanding Comedic Comic
Outstanding Dramatic Comic
Outstanding Long Form Comic
Outstanding Short Form Comic
Outstanding Story Concept
Outstanding Anthropomorphic Comic
Outstanding Fantasy Comic
Outstanding Gaming Comic
Outstanding Reality Comic
Outstanding Romantic Comic
Outstanding Science Fiction Comic
Outstanding Superhero/Action Comic

[edit] 2005

Outstanding Comic
presented by Brian Carroll of Instant Classic
Outstanding Newcomer
presented by Liz Groenveld of Stuff Sucks
Outstanding Artist
presented by Jeph Jacques of Questionable Content
Outstanding Writer
presented by Charles Snow of Sordid City Blues
Outstanding Black and White Art
presented by Jason Sigala of Niego
Outstanding Use of Color
presented by William G of It's About Girls
Outstanding Character Art
presented by James Turner of Beaver and Steve
Outstanding New Character Design
presented by Mark Mekkes of Zortic
Outstanding Environment Design
presented by Pendleton Ward of Bueno the Bear
Outstanding Layout
presented by Mikey Heller of Handicapped Sven and Yon
Outstanding Use of Flash
presented by Ryan Estrada of ryanestrada.com
  • Alpha Shade by Christopher Brudlos & Joseph Brudlos (Winner)
  • The Discovery of Spoons by Alexander Danner & John Barber (Winner)
  • Acid Keg by Steve Hogan
  • The Discovery of Spoons by Alexander Danner & John Barber
  • Green: Wicked Wicked Ways by Thomas Clemmons & Gary Burch
Outstanding Use of Infinite Canvas
presented by Tyler Sticka of tylersticka.com
Outstanding Website Design
presented by Behrooz Shahriari of Acid Dimensions
Outstanding Character (Writing)
presented by David Tekiela of Comet 7
Outstanding Comedic Comic
presented by Chris Bishop of Her! Girl vs Pig
Outstanding Dramatic Comic
presented by Joseph Park of Eden-cafe.org
Outstanding Long Form Comic
presented by Edward J. Grugg III of If Nobody Likes Me, Why am I so Popular?
Outstanding Short Form Comic
presented by Ben Gamboa of Tweep
Outstanding Story Concept
presented by Jason Rainey of jae.imperialotter.com
Outstanding Anthropomorphic Comic
presented by Anne Moloney of Boy Howdy
Outstanding Fantasy Comic
presented by Andrea L. Peterson of No Rest for the Wicked
Outstanding Gaming Comic
presented by Jason Sigala of Niego
Outstanding Reality Comic
presented by Ryan Sias of Silent Kimbly
Outstanding Romantic Comic
presented by Al Nennig of Tree Sprocket
Outstanding Science Fiction Comic
presented by Shaun Henderson of Pimp Ass Mandroid
Outstanding Superhero/Action Comic
presented by Nat Gertler of Licensable Bear™

[edit] 2006

The results of the 2006 WCCA were announced on 2006-07-17. The (delayed) ceremony was introduced by the characters of Kristofer Straub.

Outstanding Comic
presented by Tom Brazleton of Theater Hopper
Outstanding Newcomer
presented by Peter Venables of 13 Seconds
Outstanding Artist
presented by Gordon McAlpin of Multiplex
Outstanding Black and White Art
presented by Liz Walsh of The Tao of Geek
Outstanding Character Art
presented by Edward J Grug III and Jessica McLeod of Monster and Robot
Outstanding New Character Design
presented by KC Green of Horribleville
Outstanding Environment Design
presented by Jess Calcaben of "dreams in synergy"
Outstanding Layout
presented by Joe Zabel of The Ice Queen
Outstanding Use of Color
presented by Richard White of Infinite Stupidity
Outstanding Use of Flash
presented by The Ryans: North, Sias and Estrada
Outstanding Use of Infinite Canvas
presented by Bryan Chojnowski of Muffin Time
Outstanding Web Design
presented by Ken Vermette
Outstanding Writer
presented by Reva Sharp of Synchronism
Outstanding Character Writing
presented by Ben Gamboa of Tweep and M.Neils of Pocket Kitten
Outstanding Dramatic Comic
presented byLucas Daniels and Cannan Jacobs of Holy Bibble
Outstanding Comedic Comic
presented by Jon Scrivens of Little Terrors and Eddie 'Eddache' Bowley of Ed Egg
Outstanding Long Form Comic
presented by Paul Gadzikowski of Arthur, King of Time and Space
Outstanding Short Form Comic
presented by Zach Weiner of Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal
Outstanding Single Panel Comic
presented by Josh Rosen of Edwitch
Outstanding Story Concept
presented by Kane Lynch of Quamran
Outstanding Anthropomorphic Comic
presented by Sheryl Schopfer of Deer Me
Outstanding Fantasy Comic
presented by Rhea Halter of Tasha's World
Outstanding Gaming Comic
presented by Zack Giallongo of The Tenth Life of Pishio the Cat
Outstanding Slice-of-Life Comic
presented by Chad Diez of Today: The Comic
Outstanding Romantic Comic
presented by Katie Cook of The Monster's Republic of Monstaria and The Smashy Adventures of the Hulk
Outstanding Science Fiction Comic
presented by Matthew Simpson and Shimoroka Kemryu Gotax of Nuclear Powered Toaster
Outstanding Superhero/Action Comic
presented by Michael Wszelaki of Ultimate X: The Comic

[edit] External links

  • Official site: CCAwards.com
  • 2006 ceremony, externally hosted for technical reasons - [3]